Oct 28, 2009

WhatsApp Messenger (vs Ping!)


by WhatsApp Inc. (v2.1 reviewed)

Category: Social Networking
Price: $0.99

The story so far:
There are two schools of thought in app development. One believes that being first is more important. The other believes in being the best. The 'First' camp aims to capture a large user base in a short time, locking them in so that when the 'Best' app eventually appears, most users won't switch. This is similar to that Stephen King novel, "Misery", but without the car crash or creepy fat woman, just iPhone users lying in bed all day, unable to move. A familiar picture, you'll agree.

Once out the door and an established brand name, the First app is free to improve itself. From there, it's a downhill battle. Nowhere is this strategy more effective than in social networking, where the technologically-impaired burden their brighter and arguably more attractive geeky friends and keep them tied to inferior services *cough*twitter*. Unfortunately for the First camp, the App Store is a cruel frontierland where logic gets shot to pieces while sleeping in bed, with his wife and several heads of cattle taken at the pleasure of fart-happy bandits.

Consider the tale of WhatsApp Messenger, an iPhone-to-iPhone hybrid SMS/chat app not unlike RIM's Blackberry Messenger. It arrived before its recently-popular challenger, Ping!, but failed to get traction. Ping arrived later, but did the smart thing: it was free for a few precious days. Like chlamydia, it spread within groups of close friends almost instantly. So when it started charging 99c, it was an easy buy for anyone who already knew a few people using it.

And yet today, barely a week since we recommended Ping! to an adoring readership of my mother and the girl I kidnapped from a playground 18 years ago, WhatsApp Messenger is king and everyone's using it. Not Ping.

How this happened:
In layman's terms, WhatsApp fought fire with Satanic worship. They turned out a 2.0 version that was clearly the Best app, and made it free for a few days – straight out of the Ping playbook. The cost of switching for most people who'd gotten Ping for free was zero. Say what you will about the stupidity of the general population and their propensity for doing shots of single malt whisky and driving SUVs in the city, but they know a good deal (and better chat app) when they see one.

Here's what WhatsApp Messenger does better than Ping:
  • Contacts are added automatically; if their numbers are in your address book, they're on your list.
  • There's a goddamned contact list. Ping is like trying to dial in the dark with your nose.
  • Status messages. (I'm home, sick!)
  • If you're offline when a message is sent, you get it when you're back. There's nothing like getting a booty call the next afternoon when your girlfriend's playing Cooking Dash.
  • Messages don't get cut off for being too long. What's too long? Ask Gary Fung.
  • It's made by a registered company, not some dude named Gary Fung.
Here what Ping does better than WhatsApp Messenger:
  • Anonymous sexy chat without giving out your phone number.
  • Pervert.

-----
Positives: Highly polished, does more than messaging, finds your friends.
Unpositives: Still a proprietary messaging network, so our earlier criticisms apply.
Final Rating: 4 / 5

Buy WhatsApp Messenger in the iTunes App Store.
-----



11 comments:

  1. They use to support blackberry what happen now. Will we ever get a chance to chat with BB contacts as well?
    ReplyDelete
  2. Why on earth would you want to chat with _those_ people?

    I believe the Blackberry version has been held up because of issues on RIM's end of things. See this blog post for more info: http://whatsapp.wordpress.com/2009/07/11/question/
    ReplyDelete
  3. ok, let me clear up a few things. first of all, awesome review. second: we had a BB version of WhatsApp which did not have chat and thus was quite lame. we are working on adding chat into our BB version and hope to have it in beta next week. the blogpost about RIM has nothing to do with our app development, that was just me bitching about RIM charging for push notifications. but we found a way around it:)

    -- whatsapp team
    ReplyDelete
  4. Jokes aside, I do have a few friends with Blackberrys so that new version will be very welcome. Thanks for coming by, and I hope that workaround stays working for you.
    ReplyDelete
  5. BTW someone suggested calling it WhatsAppening. Bro.
    ReplyDelete
  6. Both apps were free when they first came out. Was the author paid to write this review?
    ReplyDelete
  7. If both apps were initially free, we regret the error. That would actually give more credit to Ping for being the first to experience exponential growth, but that doesn't change the fact that WhatsApp is currently a better product.

    If there's a world where writers can be paid to say "our sponsor's app was first and they even gave it away, but it sucked so hard that nobody wanted it", then that's kinda cool.
    ReplyDelete
  8. Guys, you should check out Yak, its the new kid on the block with group chats as well as the important features.. So much more reliable/stable than the others. it also has 1.1 in review (cosmetic changes and photo messages).

    Thought I'd add it to the mix!
    ReplyDelete
  9. ....more stable? First of all.... I hate anonymous trolls, seriously.
    Second: Yak could be the next Facebook as far as I know but the comment really sounds LAME.
    ReplyDelete
  10. Try VeryChat it's an application BBM like for Iphone

    and it's FREE

    http://itunes.apple.com/fr/app/verychat/id337492287?mt=8
    ReplyDelete
  11. unique topic & excellent blog post
    ReplyDelete